Wednesday, February 07, 2024

In vitro vs. In vivo Performance of Gastric Retentive Dosage Forms: Bridging the Gap

Gastric retentive dosage forms (GRDFs) have seen significant progress in recent years, driven by their potential to improve drug delivery and patient compliance. Some key recent developments include multi-mechanistic approaches, and magnetic systems. In multi-mechanistic approaches, a combination of different mechanisms like floating, swelling, and bio-adhesion is used to achieve more robust and consistent gastric retention, even in the fasted state. And, in magnetic systems, magnetic nanoparticles are used within the dosage form allows for external control of its movement and positioning within the stomach. This allows a more precise drug delivery.

In the last few years, advanced materials and complicated manufacturing technology have also been applied in the GRDFs. New polymers with tailored properties are being developed to offer improved biocompatibility, controlled release profiles, and enhanced gastric retention capabilities. 3D printing technology allows for the creation of complex and customized GRDFs with precise drug distribution and release characteristics.

In clinical translation, more products are reached the market and patient compliance is improved. Several GRDFs have been approved by regulatory agencies in recent years, demonstrating the potential of this technology for clinical use. In improved patient compliance, GRDFs can reduce dosing frequency, which can improve patient adherence to treatment regimens.

Challenge: In vitro vs. in vivo performance

Accurately predicting the in vivo performance of GRDFs based on in vitro experiments remains a significant challenge. While in vitro tests offer valuable insights into the formulation's basic properties, the complex and dynamic environment of the human stomach introduces several factors not easily replicated in the lab. Here's a deeper look at the discrepancies and ongoing efforts to bridge the gap:

Key Discrepancies:

  • Dynamic vs. Static Conditions: In vitro tests typically use static media with fixed pH and agitation, while the stomach exhibits a dynamic environment with changing pH, viscosity, and gastric emptying rate. This can significantly impact the performance of GRDFs, like floating systems, whose buoyancy depends on gastric fluids.
  • Fed vs. Fasted State: Most in vitro tests are conducted in simulated fasted state conditions, but food intake significantly alters gastric motility and fluid composition, affecting GRDF behavior. Developing biorelevant fed-state dissolution methods is crucial for improved prediction.
  • Interindividual Variability: Stomach anatomy, physiology, and emptying rate vary considerably between individuals, impacting GRDF performance. In vitro models often lack this variability, potentially leading to misleading results.

Bridging the Gap:

  • Advanced In vitro Models: Researchers are developing more sophisticated in vitro models incorporating aspects of gastric physiology, like peristaltic movements and fed-state conditions. These models provide a more realistic environment for evaluating GRDFs.
  • Multi-method Approach: Utilizing a combination of in vitro tests with different dissolution media, agitation conditions, and biorelevant fed-state models can offer a more comprehensive understanding of GRDF behavior.
  • In silico Modeling: Computational simulations based on physiological data can predict the in vivo behavior of GRDFs, complementing in vitro experiments and informing formulation design.

Despite the challenges, researchers are continuously advancing in vitro models and methodologies to bridge the gap with in vivo performance. Combining these efforts within silico modeling holds great promise for optimizing GRDF design and ultimately achieving more predictable and effective drug delivery in the complex environment of the human stomach.

 

References:

Felix Schneider, et al, In Vitro and In Vivo Test Methods for the Evaluation of Gastroretentive Dosage Forms, Pharmaceutics. 2019 Aug; 11(8): 416.

Liza Józsa et al, Recent Options and Techniques to Assess Improved Bioavailability: In Vitro and Ex Vivo Methods, Pharmaceutics. 2023 Apr; 15(4): 1146.

Dhaivat C Parikh et al, In vitro and in vivo techniques to assess the performance of gastro-retentive drug delivery systems: a review, Expert Opin Drug Deliv . 2008 Sep;5(9):951-65.